Two .40 pistols at pawnshop which one to get??

Discussion in 'Firearms' started by johnski, Nov 13, 2017.

  1. johnski

    johnski Well-Known Member

    1,669
    35
    48
    There's a Beretta Cougar 8040 and a Ruger P94 40 at a local pawnshop near me, both in good condition (90%+). Which is the better pistol of these two? Opinions please. Just these two.
     
    Last edited: Nov 14, 2017
  2. Phil1979

    Phil1979 Member Georgia Carry

    11,495
    600
    113
    If both are the same price, then the Cougar is the better one.

    A buddy of mine had a P95 9mm that was a jammomatic. But I've always heard the P95 was a good reliable pistol. Maybe he just had a lemon.
     

  3. johnski

    johnski Well-Known Member

    1,669
    35
    48
    Sorry it's a P94 not 95
     
  4. Verbal101

    Verbal101 Active Member

    2,133
    14
    38
    My first semi-auto pistol was a Ruger P series. I bought it because I liked Ruger revolvers. I never cared much for the P series, it felt clunky in my hand and I didn't shoot it well (I know that was me, though, not the gun). All things being equal, I would try the Beretta (although I've had both the PX4 Storm and 92, and like the Ruger, those grips didn't fit my hand well, either).

    Good luck & let us know how it goes.
     
  5. UtiPossidetis

    UtiPossidetis American

    3,187
    247
    63
    Beretta if they are same condition and roughly the same price. No doubt.
     
  6. Adam5

    Adam5 Atlanta Overwatch

    13,613
    158
    63
    I feel that the Cougars are better shooters, in my opinion anyway.
     
  7. johnski

    johnski Well-Known Member

    1,669
    35
    48
    And how would the sig sauer sp 2340 compare to these two?
     
  8. Adam5

    Adam5 Atlanta Overwatch

    13,613
    158
    63
    I have an SP2022 9mm that I love. If you are looking at an 2340, handle it first. The grip is a little thick for some people.
     
  9. johnski

    johnski Well-Known Member

    1,669
    35
    48
    Tough decsion. All three pistols are in .40, which is what I am looking for, all are later model pistols. The Cougar, P-94 and Sig sp22340. Leaning toward the Sig atm. The Cougar is nice and I like Berettas, but that ungodly high bore axis. Well all of them seem to have a high bore axis. The Sig SP looks nicer than the other two. The P94... I don't know why but I've always kind of wanted one. It does seem to be the red-headed stepchild of the three. Then there is Mr Ruger's penchance for supporting gun control. I think I will get the Sig. Thanks for the replies.
     
  10. wallacem

    wallacem Member

    145
    1
    18
    Never tried a Beretta in 40 but I have a P94 that is great. I like all the P series guns. Wallacem inGa
     
  11. johnski

    johnski Well-Known Member

    1,669
    35
    48
    Thanks I ended up with the Sig Sp 2340. I like it a lot. Snagged2 12-round "leo/govt only" mags off auction for a good price. I would still like to pick up a P94.
     
  12. Adam5

    Adam5 Atlanta Overwatch

    13,613
    158
    63
    You will like the 2340. I shoot and at times carry and 2009, it’s 9mm brother.
     
  13. johnski

    johnski Well-Known Member

    1,669
    35
    48
    It's virtually in brand new condition.

    sig2340.jpg
     
  14. Nemo

    Nemo Man of Myth and Legend

    12,834
    827
    113
    Shoulda got them both.

    Nemo
     
  15. Baba Yaga

    Baba Yaga Active Member

    288
    41
    28
    I have a P91DC that is not that different than the P94. Love my P91 also in .40. Fantastic shooter, and yes, built like a tank. It's also backup to my Beretta!

    But I'm gonna say, any one of them is a good choice as long as YOU think so.
     
  16. gunsmoker

    gunsmoker Lawyer and Gun Activist

    27,543
    687
    113
    Let's hear a range report on the Sig 2340 when you get a chance.
    Between the ones mentioned in this thread, I'd have used these criteria to make the choice:

    (1) What fits my hand better. What gun feels better. (reach to trigger in DA mode, thickness of grip frame, bore axis, etc.)

    (2) Which gun has the smoother and lighter DA trigger pull (I assume they all have good single action triggers).

    (3) Price, both of the gun and the extra mag or two that I'd want for it.

    (4) Availability of aftermarket parts and accessories. Night vision sights? Laser sighting systems? Bone-in holster that matches the gun's contours and controls? What kind of future upgrades can I do to each of these guns?
     
  17. papadaca

    papadaca Member

    251
    0
    16
    In the case of older all semi-autos I would go with the Beretta. Remember Beretta has made firearms for 500 years Ruger I'm not sure if they're even 100 years.
     
  18. Nemo

    Nemo Man of Myth and Legend

    12,834
    827
    113
    I had a Ruger Mini-14. I bought it a good while back. It had engraving on the side of
    1956 Ruger 1976.

    My math says Ruger has 63 years behind them.

    Nemo
     
  19. Mike J

    Mike J Member

    189
    12
    18
    I have a .40 caliber P94 that I bought new in '99. I wound up going a different direction & moved away from it after I started carrying. It is a reliable pistol. I did better with a hogue grip. I had a hard time holding on to the stock grips. I really didn't know much when I bought it. I would have liked it better if it had been the decocker only version instead of the safety version. I don't like slide mounted safeties.