Georgia Firearm Forums - Georgia Packing banner
4741 - 4760 of 4837 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
10,746 Posts
Not a good idea because it would take a constitutional amendment to switch from an income tax to a sales tax. Without it we could end up with both. the national sales tax (AKA: the Fair Tax) would be better for most people in the middle class. Being taxed on what you spend and not what you make would allow for better savings and reduce personal debt. Still you need to put an end to the income tax first.
There is a fundamental problem with the Fair Tax where the middle class will foot most of the bill anyway. It will not pass in a form where it applies to buying and selling of companies and stock and the income prebate cutoff would be too low to help non-poverty families.

You want to spend $10M buying a business? You won’t pay $1M on taxes for that even if the Fair Tax is 10%. What about the sales tax the business pays? Well, if it’s wholesale or B2B, it’s exempt anyway or else we’ve enacted VAT. Say it’s not in those categories though, like a middle tier appliance shop or something…the sales tax is passed back to middle class in a disproportionate manner because a refrigerator or washer/dryer winds up being a significant portion of income for a family on $85k/yr but pocket change to one on $600k/yr.
 

· Super Moderator
Joined
·
75,784 Posts
There is a fundamental problem with the Fair Tax where the middle class will foot most of the bill anyway. It will not pass in a form where it applies to buying and selling of companies and stock and the income prebate cutoff would be too low to help non-poverty families.

You want to spend $10M buying a business? You won’t pay $1M on taxes for that even if the Fair Tax is 10%. What about the sales tax the business pays? Well, if it’s wholesale or B2B, it’s exempt anyway or else we’ve enacted VAT. Say it’s not in those categories though, like a middle tier appliance shop or something…the sales tax is passed back to middle class in a disproportionate manner because a refrigerator or washer/dryer winds up being a significant portion of income for a family on $85k/yr but pocket change to one on $600k/yr.
It intentionally does not tax investment, so as to encourage it.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
10,746 Posts
It intentionally does not tax investment, so as to encourage it.
Reinforcing the point there. If there is a switch from taxing income to taxing luxury spending, then one of three things happens. Percent of revenue spent on luxury items spikes in theory because it makes the math look right-ish, the middle class absorbs the revenue drop, or we mortgage the next generations just that much more.
 

· Man of Myth and Legend
Joined
·
21,195 Posts
Took me a minute.

Nemo
 

· Registered
Joined
·
11,959 Posts
4741 - 4760 of 4837 Posts
Top