Georgia Firearm Forums - Georgia Packing banner
1 - 16 of 16 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,216 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I got to wondering how the law and LE would view striking someone with the butt of a pistol or long gun. Granted, a gun is a deadly weapon, and you would be using that weapon to assault someone, but in this case, it it used and is no more deadly than a broomstick or pipe wrench. Does it make any difference that it is also a fire arm? Any difference if it's loaded or not?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,075 Posts
Deadly force is generally defined as force that is intended or likely to cause death.

Your question is hard to answer definitively as so much would be determined by interpretation of actions and intent as well as your justification.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,216 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
legacy38 said:
Deadly force is generally defined as force that is intended or likely to cause death.

Your question is hard to answer definitively as so much would be determined by interpretation of actions and intent as well as your justification.
I guess I'm asking if it would be simple "Assault and Battery" or "Assault and Battery With A Deadly Weapon"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,075 Posts
Sine Nomen said:
legacy38 said:
Deadly force is generally defined as force that is intended or likely to cause death.

Your question is hard to answer definitively as so much would be determined by interpretation of actions and intent as well as your justification.
I guess I'm asking if it would be simple "Assault and Battery" or "Assault and Battery With A Deadly Weapon"
Assault and Battery are completely separate charges in GA, and there are varying levels of each.

Assault with a deadly weapon would be Aggravated Assault.

Of course none of the above would apply if you were legally justified to use said force. :wink:

See 16-5-20 through 16-5-24 of the Georgia code.
 

·
Token Liberal Hippie
Joined
·
13,680 Posts
legacy38 said:
Sine Nomen said:
legacy38 said:
Deadly force is generally defined as force that is intended or likely to cause death.

Your question is hard to answer definitively as so much would be determined by interpretation of actions and intent as well as your justification.
I guess I'm asking if it would be simple "Assault and Battery" or "Assault and Battery With A Deadly Weapon"
Assault and Battery are completely separate charges in GA, and there are varying levels of each.

Assault with a deadly weapon would be Aggravated Assault.

Of course none of the above would apply if you were legally justified to use said force. :wink:

See 16-5-20 through 16-5-24 of the Georgia code.
If he was justified to use such force, wouldn't he be just as justified in pulling the trigger?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,216 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
gsusnake said:
legacy38 said:
Sine Nomen said:
legacy38 said:
Deadly force is generally defined as force that is intended or likely to cause death.

Your question is hard to answer definitively as so much would be determined by interpretation of actions and intent as well as your justification.
I guess I'm asking if it would be simple "Assault and Battery" or "Assault and Battery With A Deadly Weapon"
Assault and Battery are completely separate charges in GA, and there are varying levels of each.

Assault with a deadly weapon would be Aggravated Assault.

Of course none of the above would apply if you were legally justified to use said force. :wink:

See 16-5-20 through 16-5-24 of the Georgia code.
If he was justified to use such force, wouldn't he be just as justified in pulling the trigger?
I know that I cannot ethically or legally shoot someone for trying to steal my bicycle, but could I beat the crap out of him in as much as would be needed to make him leave me and my bike alone? (This is not a real situation, just something I came up with on the spot.)
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
16,485 Posts
gsusnake said:
legacy38 said:
Sine Nomen said:
legacy38 said:
Deadly force is generally defined as force that is intended or likely to cause death.

Your question is hard to answer definitively as so much would be determined by interpretation of actions and intent as well as your justification.
I guess I'm asking if it would be simple "Assault and Battery" or "Assault and Battery With A Deadly Weapon"
Assault and Battery are completely separate charges in GA, and there are varying levels of each.

Assault with a deadly weapon would be Aggravated Assault.

Of course none of the above would apply if you were legally justified to use said force. :wink:

See 16-5-20 through 16-5-24 of the Georgia code.
If he was justified to use such force, wouldn't he be just as justified in pulling the trigger?
Maybe it's a 47 ninjas scenario and he's run out of reloads ;)
 

·
Lawyer and Gun Activist
Joined
·
28,608 Posts
Yes

If you assault a person with a deadly weapon, illegally, it's aggravated assault. Agg. Assault is a 20-year felony. If you assault a person with your bare hands or a tool or instrument that is not a "deadly weapon," and you don't actually cause serious bodily injury to them, it's likely to be a misdemeanor charge.

Now, the question before us is this: Is a gun always a "deadly weapon" even if it's not used as a gun, but just as a club?

YES, if the victim reasonably feared being shot with it. It doesn't matter if the gun was factually unloaded or incapable of firing for any other reason, so long as the person being assaulted thought that he might get shot with that gun. See, e.g. Williams v. State, 208 Ga. App. 12; 430 S.E. 2d 157 (1993); Veal v. State, 191 Ga. App. 445, 382 S.E. 2d 131 (1989) (gun was loaded with blanks).

YES, if a JURY finds that it is. Generally, a firearm is a "per se" deadly weapon. All guns are deadly weapons, regardless of caliber, configuration, etc. But there is an exception for guns that are wielded and brandished only as clubs, such that the victim can only fear being struck a blow with one, not fired upon.
In such a case, the determination as to whether that gun is a "deadly weapon" will be for the jury to determine, based on either the physical characteristics of the tool itself, or the circumstances of how it was used and what injury, if any, did result. e.g. [/u]Chancey v. State, 258 Ga. App 319, 574 S.E. 2d 383 (2002) (length of chain can be deadly weapon).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,216 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Re: Yes

gunsmoker said:
If you assault a person with a deadly weapon, illegally, it's aggravated assault. Agg. Assault is a 20-year felony. If you assault a person with your bare hands or a tool or instrument that is not a "deadly weapon," and you don't actually cause serious bodily injury to them, it's likely to be a misdemeanor charge.

Now, the question before us is this: Is a gun always a "deadly weapon" even if it's not used as a gun, but just as a club?

YES, if the victim reasonably feared being shot with it. It doesn't matter if the gun was factually unloaded or incapable of firing for any other reason, so long as the person being assaulted thought that he might get shot with that gun. See, e.g. Williams v. State, 208 Ga. App. 12; 430 S.E. 2d 157 (1993); Veal v. State, 191 Ga. App. 445, 382 S.E. 2d 131 (1989) (gun was loaded with blanks).

YES, if a JURY finds that it is. Generally, a firearm is a "per se" deadly weapon. All guns are deadly weapons, regardless of caliber, configuration, etc. But there is an exception for guns that are wielded and brandished only as clubs, such that the victim can only fear being struck a blow with one, not fired upon.
In such a case, the determination as to whether that gun is a "deadly weapon" will be for the jury to determine, based on either the physical characteristics of the tool itself, or the circumstances of how it was used and what injury, if any, did result. e.g. [/u]Chancey v. State, 258 Ga. App 319, 574 S.E. 2d 383 (2002) (length of chain can be deadly weapon).
Thank You for the excellent response. That is exactly what I was wondering.
 

·
Token Liberal Hippie
Joined
·
13,680 Posts
Tinkerhell said:
So be sure you tape it to the end of a baseball bat before you beat someone with your firearm.

:lol:
And make sure it's clear packing tape, not duct tape.

Gotta make sure it's in plain view.
 
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
Top